How to Find an Editor

by Maria Iliffe-Wood

How to Find an Editor

(And How Much Does it Cost?)

You know the type of edit your manuscript is ready for (because you read my previous articles) and now you want to know how to find an editor and how much you are in for. Before you go looking for your editor, there is one more thing you need to be clear on; what genre is your book? Editors have preferences for the books they want to work on and the kind of book they are skilled at working with. For example, if your book is poetry, then you don’t want to send your manuscript to an editor who specialises in historical fiction. Also, some editors prefer to do certain kinds of editing. Believe it or not, there are people who prefer proofreading – thank goodness! So now you’re ready to find an editor – let’s dive in.

I’m going to put a caveat on this article before I start. These are ways I have found editors that worked for me. There will be other ways too, I’m sure.

Who do you know?

Let’s start with who you know. Do you know an editor? Do you know anyone who might know an editor? (Like me, for instance!) Have any of your friends published a book and used an editor? Who did they use? And would they recommend the person? It doesn’t mean that because your friend had a good experience with an editor for their historical fiction, that you should use the same editor for your self-help coaching book, but that person might know someone – you know – six degrees of separation and all that! It is a good starting point. That person may know someone else who could be a perfect fit. For my first edit, I spoke to my writing teacher. She put me in touch with someone who was not only an editor, but a perfect editor for my book. Some of the other editors I have used have also come through word of mouth.

Reedsy

Then there’s Reedsy.com. This is a fabulous website for writers. It is US based but the services are available worldwide. Reedsy has vetted all the professionals. You know you are going to get someone proficient. The Reedsy Marketplace is a great place to find someone to do any aspect of helping you to get a book out into the world, from editing, to formatting, to advertising, to translating, to ghost-writing and the list goes on. You could go onto the marketplace page, add your details and leave it to chance who picks up your offer, but I recommend a bit of research.

Before you upload your project to the website, you will need a synopsis of the manuscript, a sample of about 3000 words, a note of the word-count, some words about your target market, and the current status of your book. Once you have those, you fill in your details, upload your sample (not the full manuscript at this stage) and the system will come up with a list of potential collaborators (editors, in this case).

Before you submit the project, I would go through and read the write-ups, look at their reviews, look at examples of their work (if appropriate – probably not so with editing) and get a feel for the person. One of my criteria was that they could work with English grammar and punctuation rules. I identified about half a dozen people I got a good feeling about and invited each of them to consider my project.

The editors will read the uploaded document, and if the writing interests them, they might do a sample edit and provide a quote based on that and the word-count. Some people I selected declined the project straight away, because they were too busy to meet my deadlines, which is why you need to invite at least six people, but others were interested and supplied a quote.

Before I made a final decision, I asked for a zoom meeting to get to know them and asked for a sample of their editing. I wanted to get a feel for the feedback they would provide, and the process by which they would do that. The sample edit I paid for, but it was a worthwhile investment. I found two talented editors through this process.

Reedsy is not the only platform that offer this kind of service, but it’s the only one I have come across, so far, that is specific to book writing and publishing. You might find people on Upwork, or Fiverr, for example.

Jericho et al

In the UK you can also access editing support through Jericho Writers. It’s not a procurement service in the same way as Reedsy. You buy the service from Jericho, and they will allocate the editor. I haven’t used this service, but I have attended conferences and webinars, and every interaction has been a delight.

How much will it cost?

Of course, you want to know how much it is going to cost. Some editors charge by word, some charge by the hour. The best way to find out how they charge is to ask them. But there are places you can go to get a rough idea, even before you start your search.

Reedsy is a good starting place to find out average costs. Each year they post an article about the costs of editing over the previous year.

With Jericho you can look at the various editorial services, key in your word-count and it will come up with a figure for you.

As an example, I have paid between £850 and £1550 for various edits. I had four different editors review the book at various stages. Remember, you might need multiple edits. It’s not a one-off cost. A proofread is often the cheapest type of edit, but this assumes that your manuscript has had other edits before that.

Developmental edits, or line edits, will cost you more, because these are the most detailed and take the most amount of time. One other factor that has the potential to affect the cost of an editor is how much time and effort you are prepared to spend in crafting your writing. If you have done as much as you can, the time it might take the editor will be less, which will reduce the cost. The more work the editor has to do, the greater the cost.

There must be a cheaper way!

Now you’ve read the Reedsy report, or played with the Jericho numbers, and maybe your eyes are watering. And you’re wondering, who do you know? Who is good at grammar? Perhaps an English teacher? Or a mate who reads a lot, who could do you a favour? So I don’t have to pay this much.

I used to paint and decorate my own house. (Bear with me here!) It looked pretty good, but it didn’t bear too much scrutiny. So next time it needed it, I used a friend who did painting and decorating on the side. It was a little better than my attempt, but the corners and lines were not very straight. There were paint splashes all over the cupboards and skirting boards, and paint on all my light switches. I had to do a big job of cleaning up after him. Finally, I employed a professional house painter and decorator. First, he covered everything with polythene and dust sheets and taped down all the edges. He undid all the light switches. When he started painting, he was quick, and the paint was very smooth. He cleaned up after himself every day. When he’d finished, all the edges were perfectly straight, the joins lined up beautifully. There was not a single rogue splash of paint. Why am I talking about my decorator? Because you want your book to be as beautiful as I wanted my house to be. You do not want a ‘that’ll do’ job, you want a great job. You probably spent years writing your manuscript. It deserves the care and attention of a professional job to make it the best it can be before you put it out into the world. You are doing your book and yourself a disservice if you go for the

cheapest option. Your kid’s English teacher (apologies to all English Teachers) is the equivalent of getting someone to do the job on the side. They may correct all your punctuation and spelling mistakes, but they don’t spend all day every day assessing manuscripts to make them the best they can be.

Dip your toe in the water

If you’re worried about the cost, or you’re not sure whether it’s worth it, ask for a sample edit and see what feedback you get. Someone in the Write Community recently paid for one hour of an editor’s time to review some of her poetry. She said it was the best £60 she’d ever spent. She found her editor through the Poetry Society btw.

Test it out for yourself. Get a sample edit. You will thank me for suggesting it. Your book will thank you for doing it. Check out my sample edit service, which includes a document with tracked changes, a brief summary of the feedback, with reasons for the suggestions (where appropriate) and a one hour Zoom call – recorded.

No worries – my publisher will edit my book

Ah! Now here’s my experience, which has also been the experience of a couple of people I know. At most the publisher will give the manuscript a cursory edit. They’re not expecting to give you the qualitative feedback you would receive from a professional editor. And they may be looking over it for different reasons. For example they may be concerned about backlash, so might just be on the lookout for the ways in which the book might land them in trouble, or they’re looking to make the book more saleable, so they might ask you for more salacious detail. I’m not saying this is true of all publishers; I’m just saying that my experience of the publisher’s edit has been cursory. If you are working with a traditional publisher to get your book out into the world, and they have said they will edit the book, check out what exactly they will look for when they review your manuscript, and compare that to the types of editorial services available.

So there you have it. If you have questions, please do contact me.

If you’d like to discuss what editing support I can offer, you know how to reach me. Here’s what

Renu said this about the feedback she received for her pieces in A Different Story:

“Ria’s lack of ego involvement in her communications take the writer straight into their genuine voice. She made the whole process seem effortless with no intimidation and was prompt to return my pieces. I recommend her for her capability as well as the ease and kindness that she exercised.”

Published On: April 3, 2024Categories: Writing Toolkit, Writer's Life

If you like this post, please share on your favourite social media. :)

Pile of dollar bills - $100,000From Words to Wealth
blurred copy of dictionary definition of editorFive Types of Editing: A Quick and Easy Guide