Make your book fly

by Maria Iliffe-Wood

Make your book fly

Editing is Your Chance to Flourish as a Writer.

So many people hate editing. I hear the groan when it’s mentioned. Do I have to? I think it’s good enough. I’ve spent so long on it already, I just want to be done with it. Does it really make a difference? I’m pretty good with spelling and grammar and punctuation – so I’m ok thanks. I’ve seen books that held the promise of a brilliant story, ruined because the author published without going through an editing process. People hate editing.

Let’s flourish as a writer.

Me – I LOVE editing. Although I’d rather call it revising or crafting. For me, editing, revising, crafting, whatever we want to call it, is as much part of the creative process as writing the first draft. It can be as enjoyable, if not more so. I enjoy looking at a sentence or a paragraph and seeing if I can find a more interesting, dynamic way of expressing the same thing: or to see if I can find a new way to show the feeling and connect with the reader. I love to fill out the story or pare it right back to see the impact it makes. I love to see how taking out a few words, or entire sentences, changes the flow, or see the contrast when I swap one word out for another.

“The difference between the word rock and stone. That k suddenly stops the breath. There is a seed of silence at the edge of the sound… it feels different for -one ending of stone.” Mary Oliver, A Poetry Handbook

I love to see what it does to a piece when I move it around, how the emphasis changes. I love to play with the rhythm created by a mix of long, medium and short sentences. I love to take a piece I’ve written and start all over again to see what changes in the second writing. I love to change the line breaks to see whether it might be a poem rather than a piece of prose.

What happens to the writing as I do all this is stunning to me. I’m learning what works, and what works even more effectively. I’m gaining insights into how to make the writing resonate more strongly with the reader. I’m making the content more dynamic, and profound. And through all that I’m flourishing as a writer. So instead of thinking about editing, let’s look at ways we can flourish as a writer.

Here’s a flavour my learning, much of which has come through the experience of working with a professional editor. But I’ll talk about working with an editor in another article.

Shitty first drafts

It didn’t take me long to realise that all the good books I have ever read didn’t arrive that way. The book that got published was very different from the first draft. The first draft of any writing is NEVER as good as it could be. No matter how good I think it is when it lands on the page. It can ALWAYS be revised and crafted. Indeed, it MUST be revised and crafted. Anne Lamott called them shitty first drafts. It is liberating to know that because then we don’t have to focus on whether or not our writing is good, we can just get on with writing. As Vanessa Poster says:

“When we just dive in and write, we can come up with some really good stuff that allows our genius to shine through. The thing is, the shitty first draft is often a lot of shit with nuggets of gold. It’s the editing that polishes and allows a piece to grow into its maturity.”

Start late finish early

I always start with handwriting two or three pages in my journal. I’m not in a position to write all day every day, which means that often my writing stops short, or is missing something, because I run out of steam or time. My writing doesn’t get going until I’m at least halfway down the page, and sometimes the last few lines are superfluous, or in the wrong place. It’s common for the finished piece to have started later and finished earlier in the first draft. These things I sort out when I type it up. I don’t bother typing the first paragraphs and I leave off, or move the last few lines. I might add in some missing elements, make some simple changes, and take bits out that I can see immediately don’t add any value.

Start again

Sometimes rather than mess around with the first draft, I will rewrite it from scratch. To do this I have to let go of any ideas I liked in the first piece and see what shows up the second time around. I find it fascinating. When I interviewed Dr Amy Johnson about her writing process, she talked about how sometimes she would write pages that never got used but had to be written first to make way for what followed. Often my final piece is then a mix of both. I also love Elizabeth Jarrett Andrew’s suggestion of taking the last paragraph of a piece of writing and using that as the first lines for a new piece of writing.

Come back to it later

Once it’s typed up, I’ll leave it for a few days at least. The longer I leave it, the less attached I feel to the first draft. That enables me to look at it more objectively. I set aside A Caged Mind for almost eighteen months. And when I went back to it, it felt almost like reviewing someone else’s writing. I don’t have a particular process or order for doing any of what follows. I do what feels right in the moment. Here’s just a few things I look out for.

  • Does the structure work?
  • Would it work better if I moved it around?
  • Maybe something I wrote in the last but one paragraph would be better placed as the first, second or third paragraph or vice versa.

Pay attention to the sentences

Are there sentences that could read better? Can I make them more interesting, more dynamic? Maybe there’s a feeling missing somehow, or tension, or context. I revise and craft individual sentences. I look for ways to help the reader connect more with the writing. I pay attention to sentence length and structure. A short sentence can add pizazz. A long sentence, a la the queen of lengthy, drawn-out sentences, Virginia Woolf, can create breathlessness, a mood, novel sensations for the reader, and, used well, make for a more interesting experience for the reader.

Repetition is something I always look out for. I’m a devil for that. I make a conscious decision about whether the repetition stays. Sometimes it comes out, other times I add more in for dramatic effect.

Show, don’t tell

I review my descriptions. (Some of these will be Image Moments for the Jack Grapes Method Writers amongst us). We can use seven elements in descriptions. Expert use of these elements help to show the reader where they are and can also create tension. I have a tendency to rely heavily on four elements, which makes the writing predictable

and boring for the reader. I’ll consider whether the description feels ‘samey’ compared to other image moments and decide what other elements would work better.

“Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.” Anton Chekov

I challenge myself to use various combinations and make sure every element I choose has relevance or adds a certain ‘je ne sais quoi’ to the feel of the writing. In places where I’ve expressed a feeling, I look for ways to show the feeling rather than just tell it. If you’ve been around writing for any length of time, you will have heard the adage show not tell.

“The road to hell is paved with Adverbs” Steven King

Two things I always scout for are adverbs and gerunds. Adverbs can be identified as words that end with ly, like especially, or quietly, and gerunds are words that end with -ing. In the first draft, I often add an adverb to strengthen a sentence and yet it has the opposite effect. Nine times out of ten, I will rewrite any sentence that includes an adverb or gerund. This creates more of my desired effect compared to leaving it as is. Sometimes all I have to do is remove it. On occasion the adverb or gerund will keep its place in the writing and because of its rarity, it has a more dramatic effect.

And filler words.

As I go along, I take out filler words. I use a lot of them – I mean a lot!! Words such as so, like, that, just, and, then, also. I always do a last check to take out as many of these as I can.

Now we can correct the mistakes!

At some point we have to stop. I’ve seen that editing, revising, crafting, is something we can do till the cows come home. But there comes a point when we say enough. Then it’s time to correct the mistakes. I correct spelling mistakes, grammar and punctuation; adding in commas, full stops and semi-colons; using double or single quotation marks, or the right dash – who knew there are three kinds of dashes!

PARIS IN THE THE SPRINGTIME

It’s common for words to get double typed. So common that there are a myriad of statements to demonstrate the point, like the one above. So many people miss the repetition of the word THE. As well as ‘the’ common examples include ‘and’, ‘of’, ‘for’. I tell you, they are damned easy to miss! As the writer, my eyes are blind to them because I read what I think I’ve written, rather than see the actual words on the page.

For corrective editing, I use ProWritingAid – some people use Grammarly – other apps are available. I run my writing through ProWritingAid, which shows up most of the punctuation errors, spelling mistakes and repetitions, although these apps are not infallible. They do a lot more too, but for the rest I like to either do it myself or engage with my editor. Nowadays I always run the final manuscript past the eyes of a professional proofreader. I haven’t found an app yet, that does a good a job as my wonderful proofreader.

Here’s the invitation for you, especially if you are one of those people I mentioned who hates editing with a passion, instead of editing why not change your intention to flourishing as a writer, it’s so much more enjoyable. And if you need any help with that – you know where I am.

When I asked Anne Lewis to contribute to this article, this is what she kindly sent me:

“As a news reporter I never had the luxury of editing. However working with Maria was a different story. She made such sensitive suggestions. Her work really brought the whole intention together. She understood what I was driving at. And I was so grateful for that.”

Some of the people quoted in this story are members of the Write Community.

Published On: January 10, 2024Categories: Writing Toolkit, Writer's Life

If you like this post, please share on your favourite social media. :)

Two hands holding jigsaw pieces togetherNine Tips for Working with a Professional Editor
Am I good enoughWho am I to write a book?