Nine Tips for Working with a Professional Editor
by Maria Iliffe-Wood

I thought I could write. I’d written and published a book, so that means I was a pretty decent writer – yeah? I mean, don’t we all learn how to write in school? And yet. I didn’t know what I didn’t know.
The first time I worked with a professional editor, I had no clue what I was doing. I’d been learning about Jack Grapes Method Writing, which had given me an inkling of what was possible in my writing. I’d done a few levels and my writing style had changed – dramatically. And I knew there was a lot more to learn.
I’d drafted the manuscript for A Caged Mind. It was pretty good. The writing was already better than it would have been if I’d written it years before. I could have published it as it was. But I knew better. I knew the writing could be improved. Even though as yet I couldn’t see how. I decided to hire some help.
See it as a learning opportunity.
I engaged a professional editor, a JGMW aficionado. I had no clue how it would work. I decided to see it as a learning opportunity. I would send her five short chapters at a time and she would send me suggestions as to how to make the writing more interesting, more creative, more dynamic, more resonant for the reader. I was a diligent student. I accepted every one of her suggestions – I mean she knew better than me, didn’t she? Until one day, I didn’t agree with her.
Don’t hand over your power
I’d made all her suggested amendments in one story, but when I read it over, something was missing. I got on the phone to her. “I’m not sure about this last piece now.” I said. I sat on my office chair, with pieces of paper spread around on the floor. The pages were sprinkled with pink, yellow, blue and red post-it labels, all denoting some point or other about the writing. Next to highlighted sections of text were pencil notes in the margins. My hands were sweating. Who was I to question my editor? A twenty-year veteran in the writing world. I stared at the offending page in my hand. “Now you’re reading like a writer.” She said.
It was not the response I expected. I thought as my editor; she knew what was best for my writing. In that one sentence, I realised I was the master of my writing. I was the decision maker about what should change and what shouldn’t. I was the only person who knew what was best for my book. This laid a new foundation stone for my work with her and other editors that followed.
Foster an equal relationship
This was no ego trip. It wasn’t the end of the relationship. No, far from it. I still had a lot to learn. The relationship shifted. It was no longer student to teacher; it was writer to writer. I now understood what she meant when she said, ‘these suggestions are for your consideration only.’
I am too close to my writing to see it with any kind of objectivity, especially when I have only just written it. My editor has the benefit of distance and can read it with more of an objective eye. I know she can see things in my writing that I can’t. Having said that, the suggestions are still her subjective view.
Respect any and all suggestions
One thing I learned from working with more than one editor is that two different editors can make two different and opposing suggestions for the same piece of writing, and both views can be valid. Sharon Strimling, one author in Stories From the Muses, had a similar experience. She puts it this way.
“Different people would give me suggestions or thoughts that, not only did they contradict each other, went to show me I couldn’t find yes or no from the outside world. As they gave me the feedback, I would notice in myself if it felt right or not. It was a playground and a testing ground for me to hear my own words and the truthful expression of my heart.”
Allow suggestions to percolate
In the feedback, my editor would say things like:
Take this bit out. Add something more here. Try an Image Moment there. You’re repeating yourself. Why not try some Teeth and Mouth in this sentence? See if you can replace the adverb – say it in a different way. You need to show not tell. I don’t think this bit adds anything. This paragraph is confusing. This line is brilliant – but it doesn’t fit. (One of those ‘kill your darlings’ moments that Stephen King talks about.) And so much more.
In my eyes, she might as well have scrawled FAIL across the pages. My initial reaction was to fall into a tailspin of insecurity. The fragile part of my mind assumes the feedback can only be negative. But I had learned from my first book experience (working with two critical friends) not to pay attention to that initial response. I let my mind settle for a few days, that way, when I came to read it I could see the feedback more objectively.
You determine your revisions
After that insightful conversation, instead of accepting everything carte blanche, I took the time to mull over the suggestions. What point is she making? Does the change feel right? What difference does it make? Is this my truth? Instead of one, I now had three options:
- Accept the change.
- Disregard the suggestion.
- Do something different.
It was my decision. I let my heart decide my truth.
Don’t let your ego get in the way
Most of us writers judge our writing and deem it lacklustre. But sometimes, once in a blue moon, we write a line or a story and we love it. We love it so much that we think it’s one of the best things we’ve ever written. There was one such story in A Caged Mind.
Another of my editors (I had three in total) told me I should pull it. Was she kidding?! No way was I going to pull it. She said it didn’t have a point. She was wrong. I could answer the ‘So What?’ question in a heartbeat. I determined it would stay. But over the next few days, I kept going back to it. My answer to ‘So What?’ became weaker. After a few days of percolating, I thought you know what! She’s right. I pulled the story.
Consider the reason behind the feedback
She said the same about another chapter. When I asked her about it she said, “You’ve already told this story elsewhere in the book.” She was right. It was the same story as an earlier one, but the message was different. It was important. The answer to ‘So What?’ was cast iron. But it was not clear. I cut a whole swathe of the chapter, and rewrote the important element, making sure the point was well made.
Engage your editor in a conversation
Nowadays, the relationship with my editor is much more of a conversation. She makes suggestions; we talk them through. (Not all of them, just the biggies.) I try to understand the reasons behind her suggestions, then I decide what I’m going to do with the feedback.
These pointers add up to a fruitful and healthy relationship with my editor. I’m still learning. I benefit, my writing benefits and my reader’s benefit.
Summary
In summary, here are my nine tips for developing a healthy relationship with your professional editor.
- See it as a learning opportunity.
- Don’t hand over your power to the editor, you are the master of your writing.
- Foster an equal relationship.
- Respect any and all suggestions.
- Allow the suggestions to percolate awhile. Let your mind settle before making any final decisions.
- You determine your revisions.
- Don’t let your ego get in the way of hearing the feedback.
- Consider the reason behind the feedback.
- Engage your editor in conversation – explore why they are making at some of the suggestions.
And as a final aside, if you would like some help with your editing here’s what Judy had to say about her experience with me:
“Seeing my edited work gave me much more clarity around what to look out for and see how relatively small changes can make a huge difference in finding my voice.”


Let’s Stay In Touch